Christmas on Cape Cod has a unique charm that makes the holiday season unforgettable. If you’re spending Christmas on the Cape this year, treat yourself to a holiday dinner at one of the area’s top spots. Here’s a roundup of the best places to enjoy Christmas Eve dinner on Cape Cod.

Book Our Christmas Vacation Rentals Here!

Fishermen’s View at Sandwich Marina

If you want to celebrate Christmas Eve with a touch of tradition and an unbeatable view, head to Fishermen’s View at the Sandwich Marina. Known for its fresh seafood and stunning marina views, this Cape Cod staple will be hosting its annual “Feast of the Seven Fishes” on December 24. The Feast of the Seven Fishes, rooted in Italian Christmas Eve customs, typically involves seven different seafood dishes or preparations, making it an authentic and festive choice.

The Fishermen’s View menu will showcase seafood prepared in a variety of ways, highlighting local flavors and classic Italian techniques. You can expect fresh and flavorful dishes that honor this rich culinary tradition while enjoying the sweeping views over the marina.

Villaggio in Cotuit

For a taste of Italy on Christmas Eve, Villaggio in Cotuit is a must-visit. This authentic Italian restaurant is housed in an 18th century Federal-style building on the National Register of Historic Places, adding a historic ambiance to your holiday dinner. The chef at Villaggio brings four generations of Italian culinary tradition to the table, ensuring that every dish is crafted with care and expertise.

Villaggio’s menu is filled with comforting, flavorful Italian dishes that celebrate family recipes and authentic preparation. Here, you’ll find everything from handmade pasta to hearty main courses, each prepared with the finest ingredients. The setting in the charming, historic building only enhances the experience, making it the perfect place to gather with loved ones for a delicious Christmas Eve meal.

Prepare Christmas Dinner at Your Vacation Rental

For those who prefer a quiet, intimate holiday dinner, consider preparing Christmas dinner in the comfort of your own vacation rental. With access to fresh, local ingredients from Cape Cod markets and specialty shops, you can create a holiday meal that’s as festive as it is personal. Cooking in a vacation rental allows you to bring a bit of home with you to the Cape, whether you want to prepare a traditional roast, bake a variety of holiday cookies, or recreate a family recipe.

Cooking your Christmas meal at your rental also means you can spend quality time with loved ones without the hustle of holiday restaurant reservations. Our vacation rentals on Cape Cod come with fully equipped kitchens, allowing you to prepare a mouthwatering meal in a cozy, home-like setting.

The Pheasant in Dennis

Located in Dennis, The Pheasant offers a Christmas Eve dining experience that’s a blend of elegance and local charm. The restaurant’s cozy Red Barn setting makes it feel like you’re dining in a home away from home, complete with warm décor and a welcoming ambiance. The Pheasant’s kitchen focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients sourced from local farms and fisheries, so you’ll enjoy dishes that celebrate Cape Cod’s bounty.

On Christmas Eve, The Pheasant serves selections from its winter à la carte menu, which includes a variety of dishes from ribeye and pork chops to pasta, all prepared from scratch. The menu evolves with the seasons, so it’s full of local flavors and the best of the Cape’s ingredients.

Cuvée at Chatham Inn

For a world-class dining experience on Christmas Eve, Cuvée at Chatham Inn is the ultimate choice. Known as the #1 rated restaurant on the Cape and Islands, and one of the Top 10 restaurants in New England, Cuvée offers a Christmas-tasting menu designed by Chef Isaac Olivo and his talented team. This is where you’ll find an exceptional holiday meal crafted with the finest seasonal ingredients, prepared with a blend of sophistication and creativity.

Book Your Christmas Vacation Rental with NEVR

Spending Christmas on Cape Cod is a magical experience, and having a cozy, well-located vacation rental can make your stay even more enjoyable. New England Vacation Rentals offers a range of options across Cape Cod, including locations in Chatham, Harwich, Brewster, Orleans, Hyannis, Eastham, Truro, Dennisport, Centerville, West Barnstable, Provincetown, and West Yarmouth. Whether you’re traveling with a large family or planning a quiet holiday escape, you can find a rental that fits your needs.

With amenities like pet-friendly options, hot tubs, and fireplaces, our rentals provide all the comforts of home…and then some. Staying in one of these beautiful rentals means you’ll have a comfortable space to come back to after enjoying a festive dinner, as well as plenty of room to relax, unwind, and enjoy the holiday spirit.

Plan Your Holiday Adventure Today

Cape Cod offers a Christmas experience filled with warmth, charm, and unforgettable flavors. Whether you choose to dine at one of the Cape’s top restaurants or prepare your own holiday meal in a cozy rental, you’ll find endless ways to celebrate the season. Book your Christmas rental today!