As you begin your explorations of Cape Cod, experiencing history, beach time, and as many lobster rolls as you can find, there will be a moment—a moment that happens to everyone—where you will suddenly decide you can’t go on another minute without pizza! Don’t be bothered by this absolutely understandable craving; pizza is that one meal that is universal to all! Everyone loves a good pizza (is there really such a thing as bad pizza?), and our guide to the top five pizza places in Cape Cod we love will ensure that you get the best during your stay on Cape Cod.

Harwich Port House of Pizza, 330 MA-28 Harwich Port

One of the best things about pizza is the feelings that surround the eating of said dish. No matter where you are staying in the world at the time, that first bite brings you home, and the pizzas served at Harwich Port House of Pizza do just that! Adding in a warm and casual ambience that cements that sense of home, don’t be surprised if you run into one of our New England Vacation Rentals staff on a Friday night.

Brother’s Pizza, 608 Main Street, Dennis Port

Spacious and bright even on the darkest of days, Brother’s Pizza in Dennis Port is a local secret that we only share with our most treasured guests; if everyone discovered how good their pizzas taste, we’d never get a seat! Also, for those traveling on a budget or who just appreciate a good bargain, there’s a nearly four percent discount for paying cash.

Stone L’Oven Pizza, 280 Underpass Rd, Brewster

Tucked away in a charming New England-style cottage, it’s the aromas that first tantalize your senses and the pizza that will keep you entranced! Serving a full menu of Italian and Greek inspired dishes in addition to the stone oven pizzas that taste like heaven, the full bar will ensure that you will be toasty and happy on a cold Cape Cod day!

Castaways, 986 MA-28, South Harwich

While actually considered a family restaurant serving pretty much every style of food and food type, it’s the pizza that makes us happy since this charming and cozy establishment opened its doors, and it’s the pizza that keeps us coming back time after time! Loaded with your favorite toppings and served hot enough to burn your tongue (remember to blow on it first!), Castaways is where the locals go!

Alecsie’s House of Pizza, 181 MA-137 #3, Harwich

Sightseeing can be tiring, and a night in may sound like the perfect way to relax and recuperate for the next day’s adventures. Because Alecsie’s delivers, you won’t have to worry about whipping something up yourself to feed your hungry hoard! Offering a large selection of Greek-style pizzas, calzones, salads, and appetizers, the servings are hearty and filling.

Enjoying the Comforts of Your New England Vacation Rentals Cape Cod Escape

Whether you are eating cold leftovers in the kitchen at midnight or you just received your piping hot pizza delivery, enjoying the meal in the comfort of our Cape Cod properties adds that something special to your entire getaway—reserve yours today!